Method:
if you could keep one rule that we have for our new army book (whenever that is) what would it be?
earthshaker?
blunderbusses?
cheap slaves?
mine would be LD 10 heroes…
as i often play under 2000 pts…
thoughts?
grunts:
daemonic upgrades for warmachines…such as fear/terror causing ammo, magical attacks, or (supercheese) ammo that works like Pit of Shades from Lore of Shadow *mwa hahahaha
Grimstonefire:
I’d keep the earthshaker rule in principle, but apply it in a different way. Either that or some of the magic spells from WD presents.
Blunderbuss should have a special rule relating only to the weapon, rather than when firing as part of a unit IMO.
Method:
yea… BUT it makes the unit loads of fun…
Swissdictator:
I’m torn between Earth Shaker and Blunderbuss. I love them both, though a couple small changes I wouldn’t mind. I wouldn’t mind being able to blast away with Blunderbuss even if it means Hobgoblins, Sneaky Gits, or Orcs will get blasted too… and an option to blast monster units/giants with an alternate shot style.
Earth shaker is great, Though perhaps make enemy units roll a D6… on 1-5 they’re effected on a 6 they’re not?
I like cheap slaves, but allow us to blast at them like Skaven can! 
Willmark:
Nothing intrinsically wrong with the blunderbuss, just needs a few tweaks is all.
maelzch:
im definately in favour of being allowed to shoot where it might cause harm to any greenskin units. The CD’s are evil, and the greenies are slaves, where’s the need to save them?
Hashut’s Blessing:
grunts, daemonic upgrades don’t exist so can’t be KEPT in 
I’m torn between blunderbusses and earthshakers, either way they’d need tweaking, but if one had to be lost, I’d keep blunderbusses for some reason.
rabotak:
I´m with HB … its a hard decision, but I´d keep the BBs too… just gotta love em!
furrie:
never used a ES but my BBs where to good to get rid of them
Bassman:
The shaker! No brainer for me. Half of the fun of my battles is made of the whining of my opponent each time I approach my heartshaker for next shoot.
Blunderbusses are cool but have you seen a dwarf player’s face when he cannot shoot with his thunderers, quarrelers, cannon and organ gun? And his troops have to move 3" each turn? Aahahhahahaha :cheers
Bye Bassman
grunts:
oops, I read it as rule wanted not rule to keep. In that case, earthshaker!
Viskar Zhragoth:
Uhm, well I think BB will still exist, but the rule will probably change…But I want the Earthshaker in there for sure!