[Archive] Iffy Shadow magic question

kalz:

Ok, I cannot see a specific rule in any book about what a character is so as such here is my question if i put my lord on a lamarasu with shadow then cast a spell can i swap the wizard and his mounts ( as being mounted on a monster count as a combined profile) with my destroyer using the shadow lore attribute? I am honestly not sure if this would be allowed, but if it is :smiley: evil laugh

Grimbold Blackhammer:

I believe if you look at the Smoke and Mirrors rule you’ll find you can only swap characters around. Otherwise that would be really quite awesome!

Grimbold Blackhammer

Groznit Goregut:

Good question, though. Can you swap the lammasu for a character? What happens to the lord?

khedyarl:

Smoke and mirrors forces you to switch the same unit type. As the lamassu is a monster, I believe the lore attribute is actually completely worthless (there being no character monsters available to Chaos Dwarfs). I don’t even think that two Lamassu’s could swap, as far as its written.

metro_gnome:

I don’t think this is strictly true… Lammasu and prophet together are considered a character with unit type ā€œmonsterā€ā€¦

Should the swap occur it would require the same… I looked at the Taur’ruk and he does not fit…

but if you had another mounted prophet you should be able to swap them after a successful Shadow spell…

But as putting down that many mounted Lords doesn’t occur till nearly 5K its safe to call the shadow lore attribute next to worthless…

kalz:

But the rules don’t state a specific rule for characters so what’s to say that the destroyer couldn’t be a character? he is a 1 man unit? :stuck_out_tongue: i know i am clutching at straws but its kinda a competition we have round here :stuck_out_tongue: to see who can use the most vague unsure rules :stuck_out_tongue:

metro_gnome:

except Destroyers don’t follow the rules for characters… it cannot challenge or be challenged for example…

like I said you should be able to swap mounted prophets… otherwise there are no character targets for this attribute…

khedyarl:

Metro-gnome: They aren’t both considered a monster, and aren’t both considered a character. For example: A giant doesn’t roll on the big things chart against a Prophet, and a Lamassu doesn’t count as a character for items that get bigger with more characters around. They are seperate entities - one is a character, and one is a ridden monster.

I like the idea of playing ā€œcupsā€ with a lamassu as much as the next guy, but as of now, I don’t see how it is possible.

metro_gnome:

Page 105 BRB:
"If a character has a ridden monster, the whole model is treated as having the troop type monster and thus follows all of the rules for both characters and monster models."

It then goes on to list a bunch of exceptions… and smoke and mirrors is not one of them…
I’ve only looked at the seige giant rules in Tamurkhan…
but it would seem to suggest that ridden monsters ARE in fact treated as ā€œBIG THINGSā€ā€¦
But I will check other giant rules when I get a chance…

Far more evidence to support this swap… and its relatively rare occurance…
would definitely cause me to rule in favor of allowing it…

kalz:

That is what i was basing my initial decision on however as u say it is such a rare thing that never happens that rules are somewhat unclear :stuck_out_tongue: hey at the very least get to have some fun discussing who is right :stuck_out_tongue:

Da Crusha:

I believe there is a little bit of errata in the BRB FAQ about smoke and mirrors. cant remember what it is right now though… probably doesnt cover lammasus ;P.

metro_gnome:

well let us approach this in a different way…
suppose it is the character who is mounted that is a Shadow Wizard (which is more typical)…
can we assume that this wizard may change places with some character (say the BSB ) on foot?
This could lead to characters who do not regularly have a mount option to gain illegal mounts…
you wouldn’t even need a lord level wizard… a level 1 wizard could end up on a dragon through SaM…
I do not believe that is what was intended by smoke and mirrors… and I really do not believe it reads this way…

If the character and mount are taken as a single model that is both monster and character…
then the only legal target for SaM would be another character with the troop type monster…
in Azgorh the only other target that would fit is another mounted prophet…
though I don’t think the type of mount (Lammasu or Taurus) would matter…

furrie:

When playing a storm of magic battle, you could change it with a greater daemon when you have made a daemon pact.

metro_gnome:

well sure… and if you are using CDs as allies to WoC you could switch a Lammansu Lord with Galrauch…

Groznit Goregut:

Looking at the Shadow Magic Lore, it says you can exchange places with a character of the same troop type. A lvl 4 on Lammasu would make that whole model troop type MONSTER. So, as long as there is another character that has the same troop type, you can do it. For a pure CD army, that means you’ll need another character riding a monster to make it happen. If you played in a doubles event at Adepticon or something, you could do it with any other character on a monster, such as an Orc Warlord on a Wyvern. You could also do it with an Ancient Treeman, as that is a monster and a character. You wouldn’t be able to do it with an Empire hero on Pegasus as that’s a Monstrous Beast.

So, I say it can happen, but it’s extremely situational and not to happen in the average game.

It CAN’T happen with a K’Daai as that’s not a character, only the same troop type. It’s like saying a Shadow mage on foot can trade places with a rank and file from a unit. It just can’t happen.

khedyarl:

Yeah, looks as if Metro is definitely right on that one. Which means a Lamassu with a Prophet on top can actually swap around with another prophet on a Lamassu, or taurus, or bale taurus.