clam:
The 2nd/3rd ed Citadels - thats the C16s, the D3s, the Renegades and a few more - all came with the plain shields with the hole in the middle:
http://www.solegends.com/citcat912/c20328plastics-h.htm
Those I’ve got from NIBs all had the undead ones. And the catalogue photoes also show them with these - but there might have been variants.
The MM90’s also came with ‘undead shields’ - but it was those Marauder Miniatures did without a hole and with sculpt on motives (See my first post - post #3)
So yeah, they all came with ‘undead shields’ - just that they have two different designs.